San Diego
Federal & Immigration
Appeals Attorney
Strict Deadlines.
An appeal is not a second trial. It is a different kind of case, decided on the record that already exists, the issues that were preserved, and the quality of the written argument presented to the reviewing court.
At The Law Offices of Michael J. Codner, clients receive strategic, personalized representation in federal appellate matters involving criminal and immigration proceedings, including petitions for review in the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
Experienced Federal and Immigration Appellate Representation in San Diego
Appellate work requires a different set of skills than trial-court litigation. Instead of presenting new evidence or witnesses, the work centers on careful record review, focused legal research, written advocacy, and close attention to jurisdictional requirements and filing deadlines.
For noncitizens, a decision by an immigration judge or the Board of Immigration Appeals may determine whether they can remain in the United States. For people challenging federal criminal judgments, sentences, or other appealable rulings, the outcome of an appeal can affect liberty, career, and future. In both settings, the time to act is short and the procedural rules are demanding.
Michael J. Codner has practiced law since 2003, representing clients in complex legal matters involving California state courts, federal proceedings, criminal defense, immigration consequences, and appellate litigation. That combination of criminal and immigration experience is especially valuable when an appeal turns on how a criminal case and its immigration consequences fit together.
As a boutique San Diego law practice, the firm emphasizes direct attorney involvement, thoughtful case preparation, discretion, and legal strategies tailored to each client’s circumstances.
Federal & Immigration Appeals We Handle
The Law Offices of Michael J. Codner handles federal appellate matters arising from criminal and immigration proceedings. Every matter depends on the record, the decision being reviewed, the issues raised below, the applicable standard of review, and the law that governs the case.
Ninth Circuit Immigration Petitions for Review
When the Board of Immigration Appeals issues a final order of removal, federal law allows a noncitizen to seek review in the appropriate United States Court of Appeals. For removal proceedings completed within the Ninth Circuit, that review is generally sought by filing a petition for review in the Ninth Circuit. A petition for review generally must be filed within 30 days of the final order, and the case is then decided largely on the administrative record and written briefing. Michael prepares petitions for review and appellate briefs focused on the legal and procedural issues most likely to matter to the court.
Stays of Removal Pending Review
Filing a petition for review does not, by itself, stop removal. When a client faces the risk of removal while the case is pending, a motion asking the court to stay removal may be an important part of the strategy. Whether a stay is appropriate depends on the governing stay factors, including the strength of the legal issues and the risk of irreparable harm, as well as the circumstances of the particular case.
Federal Criminal Appeals and Related Appellate Matters
Selected federal appellate matters may arise from criminal convictions, sentences, appealable rulings, or cases in which criminal and immigration issues overlap. Michael evaluates whether appellate review is available, which issues are properly preserved and worth pursuing, and how best to present them in writing to the reviewing court.
Immigration Appellate Work and Federal-Court Review
Immigration appellate work often involves challenging how the agency applied the law to a client’s case, including how a criminal conviction was treated for immigration purposes. Michael’s work on this page focuses on federal-court review of immigration decisions, particularly petitions for review and related Ninth Circuit briefing where criminal and immigration law intersect.
Facing a Deadline to Appeal? Speak With an Experienced Attorney.
Why Appellate Work Is Different
An appeal often turns on the record and the briefing.
A reviewing court generally does not hear new testimony or consider new evidence. It reviews what happened in the court or agency below, measured against the legal standards that apply.
That means the most important work happens on paper: identifying the strongest issues in the record, confirming that they were properly preserved, researching how courts have decided similar questions, and presenting a clear, well-supported written argument.
It also means deadlines matter. Many appellate deadlines are short, and missing one can end the opportunity for review altogether.
Where the Appeal and the Underlying Case Overlap
In some federal criminal matters, appellate or post-judgment issues are closely tied to the underlying case. A sentencing decision, a plea, or a ruling on a key motion may raise issues that should be evaluated with a possible appeal in mind.
For noncitizens, the stakes are often higher still. The way a federal criminal case is resolved, and whether an appeal is pursued, may affect immigration status, eligibility for relief, and the ability to remain in the United States.
Michael recognizes the importance of evaluating these concerns together, rather than solving one problem while creating another.
Appellate Deadlines Are Strict
Waiting can cost the right to review.
In a federal criminal case, a defendant’s notice of appeal generally must be filed within 14 days after entry of the judgment or order being appealed, subject to specific rules and exceptions. A petition for review of a final order of removal generally must be filed within 30 days of the final order.
Other appellate and post-judgment procedures have their own deadlines and requirements. Because these timelines are short, it is important to seek legal guidance as soon as possible after a decision is issued.
A Strategic Approach to Federal and Appellate Cases
No two cases are identical. Effective appellate representation begins with understanding exactly what happened below.
Thorough Record Review
Every matter begins with a careful review of the record: the transcripts, filings, rulings, and the decision being challenged.
Potential issues may include whether objections and arguments were properly preserved, which standard of review applies, and whether the court or agency applied the law correctly.
Focused Legal Research and Issue Selection
Strong appeals rarely raise every possible argument. They focus on the issues with the greatest legal merit and the greatest potential impact.
Michael researches how courts have decided similar questions and provides clients with a realistic assessment of the benefits and risks of each option.
Persuasive Written Advocacy
In appellate courts, the brief is often the most important opportunity to persuade.
The firm prepares clear, well-organized, and well-supported briefing designed to present each client’s position as effectively as possible, while meeting every filing requirement and deadline.
Why Choose Michael J. Codner for Federal & Immigration Appeals?
- Practicing Law Since 2003Michael has more than two decades of legal experience, including work involving criminal defense, federal proceedings, appellate matters, immigration consequences, and post-conviction relief.
- Criminal Defense and Immigration ExperienceMany appeals turn on how a criminal case and its immigration consequences fit together. Michael’s experience in both areas helps clients understand the full picture.
- A Boutique Practice Built Around Personal RepresentationClients seeking Michael’s representation receive direct involvement from the attorney they retain, rather than a high-volume approach in which cases are routinely passed between multiple lawyers.
- Attention to What Is Truly at StakeAn appellate decision may affect liberty, immigration status, family unity, career, and reputation. The firm approaches each matter with an appreciation for the full range of potential consequences.
Serving Clients in San Diego and Appropriate Federal Appellate Matters Beyond San Diego County
The Law Offices of Michael J. Codner is located at 3020 Meade Avenue in San Diego, California.
The Law Offices of Michael J. Codner is based in San Diego and represents clients in appropriate federal and appellate matters arising in San Diego County and elsewhere when jurisdiction, venue, and admission requirements permit. The firm’s federal appellate work is record-driven and can often be handled without the client being physically located near the office.
Venue for an immigration petition for review is generally tied to the judicial circuit in which the Immigration Judge completed the removal proceedings. When those proceedings are completed within California, the petition is generally filed in the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Federal criminal cases arising in San Diego are heard in the United States District Court for the Southern District of California, with appeals generally proceeding to the Ninth Circuit.
Frequently Asked Questions
About Federal & Immigration Appeals
How is an appeal different from a trial?
An appeal is generally not a new trial. The reviewing court does not usually hear new witnesses or consider new evidence. Instead, it reviews the record from the court or agency below and decides whether legal errors were made that affected the outcome. The written briefs are often the most important part of the case.
What is a petition for review in an immigration case?
A petition for review asks a federal court of appeals to review a final order of removal or another reviewable immigration decision after the administrative process has been completed. When venue lies in the Ninth Circuit, the petition is filed there and the court reviews the agency decision under the standards that apply to the issues raised.
How long do I have to file a petition for review?
A petition for review of a final order of removal generally must be filed within 30 days of the final order. Because the deadline is short and determining finality can be complicated, it is important to seek legal advice promptly.
Does filing a petition for review stop my removal?
Not automatically. Filing the petition for review itself does not automatically stay removal. A separate stay request may be necessary. In the Ninth Circuit, filing an initial motion or request for a stay can trigger a temporary stay under the court’s procedures while the stay request is considered, but the ultimate stay determination depends on the circumstances.
How long do I have to appeal a federal criminal conviction or sentence?
In a federal criminal case, a defendant’s notice of appeal generally must be filed within 14 days after entry of the judgment or order being appealed, subject to specific rules and exceptions. Plea agreements may also contain appeal waivers that affect which issues can be raised, so the agreement should be reviewed promptly and carefully.
Can I raise new arguments or evidence on appeal?
Generally, no. Appellate courts usually decide cases based on the existing record and the issues that were raised in the court or agency below. That is why issue preservation, and careful review of what was actually argued and decided, are so important.
Can the immigration consequences of a criminal case come up on appeal?
Yes. Many immigration appeals turn on how a criminal conviction was classified for immigration purposes. Evaluating these issues requires an understanding of both the criminal record and the immigration law that applies.
Where is the law office located?
The Law Offices of Michael J. Codner is located at 3020 Meade Avenue, San Diego, CA 92116. To discuss a federal or immigration appellate matter, call or text 619-929-6394 or schedule a confidential consultation online.
Your Future Matters.
The Record Deserves Careful Review.
When a decision threatens your liberty, your immigration status, or your future, the steps you take in the days that follow can determine whether review is still available.
Whether you are facing a deadline to seek federal review of an immigration decision, considering an appeal in a federal criminal case, or need to understand whether a decision can be challenged, experienced appellate representation matters.
Michael J. Codner provides discreet, individualized legal counsel grounded in careful preparation, strategic judgment, and personal attention.
The Law Offices of Michael J. Codner
3020 Meade Avenue
San Diego, CA 92116
Call or Text: 619-929-6394
Schedule a Confidential Consultation Online
*The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Contacting the firm does not, by itself, establish an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee future outcomes.



